
Alex (Romain Duris) has his work cut out for him trying to woo Juliette (Vanessa Paradis) in HEARTBREAKER
HEARTBREAKER (L’ARNACOEUR) (Pascal Chaumeil, 2010)
IFC Center, 323 Sixth Ave. at Third St., 212-924-7771
Lincoln Plaza Cinema, 1886 Broadway at 63rd St., 212-757-2280
Opens Friday, September 10
www.ifcfilms.com
A big hit in France, Pascal Chaumeil’s debut film, HEARTBREAKER, is a ridiculously mundane romantic comedy that is neither very romantic nor much of a comedy. Romain Duris stars as Alex, a sensitive stud who earns a meager living by breaking up couples in which he has determined that the woman does not realize that she is not truly in love with her partner. Working with his sister (Julie Ferrier) and brother-in-law (François Damiens) as a kind of Impossible Mission force, he charms the women just enough so they see their unhappiness, then he walks away, claiming that he is unable to fall in love again and telling them to begin anew. In debt to a local mobster, Alex decides to take a job breaking up an impending Monte Carlo marriage between Juliette (Vanessa Paradis) and Jonathan (Andrew Lincoln) even though he believes the couple is truly in love. Going against his code, he tries to woo Juliette, but she is his toughest case yet, especially when he starts falling for her. Chaumeil previously directed sitcoms, advertisements, and series television in France, and it shows; HEARTBREAKER plays more like a TV program than a feature-length film. The plot is paper thin, the subplots just plain silly, and the humor sophomoric. The film attempts to redeem itself in the end, but it is far too late to save it from drowning in an absurd lack of originality.






Chinese film director Zhang Yimou nearly always hits the mark, having scored major successes with such outstanding early work as RED SORGHUM, JU DOU, RAISE THE RED LANTERN, THE STORY OF QIU JU, and TO LOVE as well as such more recent fare as HERO, HOUSE OF FLYING DAGGERS, RIDING ALONE FOR THOUSANDS OF MILES, and CURSE OF THE GOLDEN FLOWER. But the award-winning director, who turns sixty this year, has taken a silly turn with his latest, A WOMAN, A GUN AND A NOODLE SHOP, a farcical remake of the Coen brothers’ modern noir classic, BLOOD SIMPLE. Thought not nearly as intolerable as the Coens’ own remake flop, 2004’s THE LADYKILLERS, Yimou’s version of greed, infidelity, and double and triple crosses has a tense, thrilling ending, but much of what leads up to it is just too over the top. In a noodle shop in a nearly deserted region of China, a young woman (Yan Ni) is cheating on her much older, disgusting husband, Wang (Ni Dahong), with the hapless, weak-willed Li (Xiao Shenyang). Wang hires a dedicated soldier, Zhang (Sun Hunglei), as a private detective to catch the lovers in action and kill them. Meanwhile, Zhao (Cheng Ye) and Chen (Mao Mao), who also work in the noodle shop for Wang and his wife, primarily stay in the background as the crazy shenanigans unfold, the comic relief in a movie already overburdened with comic relief. Interspersing elements of Peking Opera and slapstick comedy, Yimou loses sight of the heart of the crooked tale, getting lost in vaudevillian set pieces that often feel out of place, although it is fun watching Li, Zhao, and Mao Mao stretch, throw, and spin around dough like they’re making a pizza. The film also features gorgeous cinematography courtesy of Zhao Xiaoding, who beautifully captures the mountainous region and the colorful costumes. But if Yan Ni screams one more time. . . .