TONY TIME: A LOOK AT EVERY NOMINATED SHOW (AND A FEW THAT WERE SNUBBED)

Tonight is the seventy-ninth annual presentation of the Tony Awards, celebrating the best in theater this past season. Twenty-four shows have been recognized among twenty-six categories.

Below is a look at every production that received at least one nomination, as well as a few that were shut out, arranged by how many nods it received. The only eligible shows I did not see were All Out and Mamma Mia!, both of which were shut out.

I refrain from making predictions, although I will share that, for me, the Best Play is The Balusters and the Best Musical is Schmigadoon!

But please feel free to argue — I’m sure there is plenty to debate.

THE LOST BOYS
Palace Theatre
1564 Broadway at 47th St.
Tuesday – Sunday through March 7, $69.75-$372.50
www.lostboysmusical.com

Peter Pan ain’t go nothing on these darling bloodsucking Lost Boys. Director Michael Arden sinks his teeth into this delicious musical adaptation of the 1987 horror comedy, with a touching book by David Hornsby and Chris Hoch and a dramatic score by the Rescues. When Lucy Emerson (Shoshana Bean) moves to the eerie town of Santa Carla, she and her two sons, Michael (LJ Benet) and Sam (Benjamin Pajak), get a whole lot more than they bargained for as Michael falls in love with Star (Maria Wirries) and develops a bromance with David (Ali Louis Bourzgui), who only comes out at night. Fantastic sets by Dane Laffrey, blasting music, and high-flying by Lauren Yalango-Grant and Christopher Cree Grant turn the Palace into a dazzling dark nightmare, even with a few silly subplots.

The Lost Boys is nominated for twelve Tonys: Best Musical, Best Book, Best Orchestrations, Best Direction, Best Choreography, Best Original Score, Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Musical (Bean), Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Musical (Bourzgui), Best Scenic Design, Best Costume Design, Best Lighting, and Best Sound.

SCHMIGADOON!
Nederlander Theatre
208 West Forty-First St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Tuesday – Sunday through January 3, $79-$349.50
schmigadoonbroadway.com

Cinco Paul does a masterful job of translating his Apple TV show, Schmigadoon!, to Broadway, where it feels it has always belonged, and has always been. Josh Skinner (Alex Brightman) and Melissa Gimble (Sara Chase) are forced to reevaluate their relationship when they wander into a magical land where every day is a musical — and are unable to leave without passing a test of the heart. The show lovingly parodies hit songs from such musicals as Carousel, The Sound of Music, The Music Man, Oklahoma!, and, of course, Brigadoon, with utter glee. The terrific ensemble boasts Ana Gasteyer as the teetotaling Mildred Layton, Brad Oscar as the conflicted Mayor Menlove, Ann Harada as his wife, Max Clayton as hunky Danny Bailey, Maulik Pancholy as the leprechaun and the minister, McKenzie Kurtz as the marriage-hungry Betsy, and Isabella McCalla as a lovely schoolteacher. It’s a candy-colored fantasy not only about musicals but about tolerance and diversity, without getting too preachy. If there’s any justice in this world, it should run forever.

Schmigadoon! is nominated for twelve Tonys: Best Musical, Best Book, Best Orchestrations, Best Direction (Christopher Gattelli), Best Choreography (Gattelli), Best Original Score, Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical (Chase), Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Musical (Gasteyer), Best Scenic Design, Best Costume Design, Best Lighting, and Best Sound.

RAGTIME
Vivian Beaumont Theater at Lincoln Center Theater
150 West 65th St. between Broadway & Amsterdam Ave.
Tuesday – Saturday through August 2, $114-$421
www.lct.org/shows/ragtime

Lear deBessonet’s breathtaking revival of Ragtime has the best opening number I’ve even seen, a spectacular introduction of the characters while setting the mood and atmosphere for a potent tale of class and racism in old New York. Based on E. L. Doctorow’s 1975 novel, which was also made into a 1981 film by Miloš Forman, the musical has a fabulous score by Stephen Flaherty and Lynn Ahrens, a hard-hitting book by Terrence McNally, and sweeping orchestrations by William David Brohn, performed by an amazing cast led by Joshua Henry as Coalhouse Walker Jr., Caissie Levy as a New Rochelle housewife, Brandon Uranowitz as new immigrant Tateh, Rodd Cyrus as Harry Houdini, Anna Grace Barlow as Evelyn Nesbit, and Nichelle Lewis as Sarah. Every minute of its nearly three-hour-length packs a punch as Walker refuses to bend his knee to societal mores. But at its heart, it’s a powerful story of parents and children.

Ragtime is nominated for eleven Tonys: Best Revival, Best Direction, Best Choreography, Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical (Uranowitz, Henry), Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical (Levy), Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Musical (Ben Levi Ross), Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Musical (Lewis), Best Costume Design, Best Lighting, and Best Sound.

CATS: THE JELLICLE BALL
Broadhurst Theatre
235 West Forty-Fourth St. between Broadway & Eighth Aves.
Tuesday – Sunday through January 17, $58-$321
catsthejellicleball.com

In June 2024, I wrote, “The Pride celebration of the summer and, hopefully, beyond is happening seven times a week at PAC NYC, where Zhailon Levingston and Bill Rauch’s electrifying reimagining of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s Cats — yes, that Cats — is running now through September 8, not quite forever, but not bad.” Its transfer to the Broadhurst is beyond disappointing; what was an engaging, involving production on a long catwalk, with the audience on three sides, is now a standard proscenium-stage musical that has lost its edge. It might be glittery and flashy, but not it’s all about the primping and voguing. Not that the story has ever been so compelling, but who cares when we have glitz galore? And what’s with those two seats onstage?

Cats: The Jellicle Ball is nominated for nine Tonys: Best Revival of a Musical, Best Orchestrations, Best Direction, Best Choreography, Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Musical (André De Shields), Best Scenic Design, Best Costume Design, Best Lighting, and Best Sound.

DEATH OF A SALESMAN
Winter Garden Theatre
1634 Broadway between 50th & 51st Sts.
Tuesday – Sunday through August 9, $99-$799
salesmanbroadway.com

Is Death of a Salesman showing its age? Joe Mantello’s revival, the seventh time Arthur Miller’s 1949 masterwork has appeared on Broadway (and third time in fourteen years), starts off well and good with a superb first act, but everything changes after intermission, except the dour, threatening industrial garage set. Nathan Lane as Willy Loman acts more like Nathan Lane, Laurie Metcalf as his devoted wife, Linda, virtually disappears (that’s the way Miller wrote it, but you feel her absence), the hotel and dinner scenes are problematic, and the graveyard ending is, well, I don’t know what to say about it. Christopher Abbott is as compelling a Biff as I’ve ever seen. Although I couldn’t tolerate the cinematic music, it is nominated for a Tony, as is Metcalf, who should have received a Best Actress nod for Little Bear Ridge Road as well. And yes, once again, my wife’s theory holds that there is trouble a-brewing any time an actual car or other motor vehicle is driven on and off a Broadway stage.

Death of a Salesman is nominated for nine Tonys: Best Revival, Best Direction, Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Play (Lane), Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Play (Abbott), Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Play (Metcalf), Best Original Score, Best Scenic Design, Best Lighting, and Best Sound.

THE ROCKY HORROR SHOW
Studio 54
254 West 54th St. between Seventh & Eighth Aves.
Tuesday – Sunday through November 29, $82-$339
www.roundabouttheatre.org

Be prepared to give yourself over to absolute pleasure in Sam Pinkleton’s outrageously fun revival of Richard O’Brien’s The Rocky Horror Show, from the second you walk into Studio 54. When Brad — asshole! — and Janet — dammit, Janet! — end up at a creepy mansion in the middle of nowhere, their happy plastic life on this planet goes rather awry as they encounter the motley crew of Riff Raff (Amber Gray), Magenta (Juliette Lewis), Columbia (Michaela Jaé Rodriguez), Rocky (Josh Rivera), Eddie (Harvey Guillén), and their deliciously wicked boss, Frank-N-Furter (Luke Evans). And it’s narrated by the hilarious Rachel Dratch, who has a blast with the audience, even if the call-outs still need some work. It’s just about everything you hoped it would be. And remember: It’s just a jump to the left, then a step to the right.

The Rocky Horror Show is nominated for nine Tonys: Best Revival, Best Choreography, Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical (Evans), Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical (Hsu, Dratch), Best Scenic Design, Best Costume Design, Best Sound, and Best Lighting, Best Director.

TWO STRANGERS (CARRY A CAKE ACROSS NEW YORK)
Longacre Theatre
220 West 48th St. between Broadway & Eighth Aves.
Tuesday – Sunday through November 22, $69-$299
twostrangersmusical.com

Broadway shows set in New York City have a difficult task getting things right, needing to satisfy tourists as well as native New Yorkers, who will immediately criticize any geographic or sociocultural mistakes while tiring of genre clichés about the City That Never Sleeps. For every Hell’s Kitchen, there’s a New York, New York. Happily, the charming Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) gets things right. Sam Tutty is adorable in his Broadway debut as Dougal Todd; you just want to run up and hug him (but please don’t). Dougal looks at the city in the way not only tourists but longtime denizens should, with wonder and happiness and promise. Christiani Pitts, who has appeared in such other New York City shows as A Bronx Tale and King Kong, is heart-wrenching as Robin, who believes she has hit a dead end and needs to be reenergized. Their chemistry is evident from their first meet-cute bump.

Two Strangers is nominated for eight Tonys: Best Musical, Best Book, Best Orchestrations, Best Original Score, Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical (Tutty), Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical (Pitts), Best Scenic Design, and Best Director.

OEDIPUS
Studio 54
254 West 54th St. between Seventh & Eighth Aves.
Closed February 8
oedipustheplay.com

Every season there seems to be one show that everyone goes gaga over except me. Last year it was Maybe Happy Ending, which won six Tonys, including Best Musical. I found it okay but couldn’t get past the plot holes and inconsistencies, as well as the inclusion of the crooner. This time around it’s Robert Icke’s modern-day adaptation of Sophocles’s Oedipus. It seems that the rest of the world is championing this production, which stars Mark Strong as Oedipus, Lesley Manville as Jocasta, an excellent John Carroll Lynch as Creon, and Anne Reid as a mystifying version of Merope. It takes place in the British political arena as Oedipus seeks to become prime minister. I’ve raved about some of Icke’s previous works (Hamlet, Oresteia, Enemy of the People), but I couldn’t connect with this one, which felt like watching election-night coverage on cable TV. However, I will now start pronouncing it as “Eedipus.”

Oedipus is nominated for seven Tonys: Best Revival, Best Direction, Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Play (Strong), Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Play (Manville), Best Scenic Design, Best Lighting, and Best Sound.

THE BALUSTERS
Samuel J. Friedman Theatre
261 West Forty-Seventh St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Tuesday – Sunday through June 21, $58-$347
www.manhattantheatreclub.com

David Lindsay-Abaire’s The Balusters takes on a kitchen sink of contemporary issues, from homophobia, racism, classism, and corruption to toxic masculinity, privilege, bigotry, and furniture. And it does so in hilarious ways; I can’t remember the last time I laughed so long and hard during a play or clapped so often after side-splitting, sparkling lines of dialogue. The hundred-minute comedy is set at several meetings of the Vernon Point Neighborhood Association, where a group of nine people regularly gather to discuss the state of their beloved community, a peaceful, old-fashioned enclave steeped in history, boasting well-manicured lawns, comfortable, attractive porches, and an overall flavor of Victorian elegance. The terrific ensemble forms an outrageously funny extended family, led by Emmy winner Richard Thomas and Tony winner Anika Noni Rose, but theater treasure Marylouise Burke steals the show as Penny, who always knows just what to say.

The Balusters is nominated for five Tonys: Best Play, Best Director (Kenny Leon), Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Play (Thomas), Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Play (Burke), and Best Costume Design.

CHESS: A COLD WAR MUSICAL
Imperial Theatre
249 West 45th St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Tuesday – Sunday through May 3, $74-$571
chessbroadway.com

The current Broadway production is the first iteration I’ve seen, and I found it to be a ton more exciting than watching, well, a chess match. Tony-winning director Michael Mayer has teamed up with Emmy-winning film and television writer, actor, and director Danny Strong, making his Broadway debut, to reimagine the show, and it’s a major triumph filled with clever and insightful moves, despite occasionally delving into soapy melodrama, while not overplaying the cold war connections between the 1980s and today. The American chess master Freddie Trumper (Aaron Tveit) is in love with his second, the beautiful theoretician Florence Vassy (Lea Michele). They are preparing for a major match against the brilliant Anatoly Sergievsky (Nicholas Christopher), whose handler is the devious Alexander Molokov (Bradley Dean), who later uses Anatoly’s estranged wife, Svetlana (Hannah Cruz), against him. As the players travel to Merano, Stockholm, and, most famously, Thailand, where they spend a memorable night in Bangkok, relationships come together and fall apart, loyalty is tested, and the SALT II treaty is hotly debated as the KGB and the CIA fight to assert their prominence. Chess is a thrilling evening of theater, highlighted by Pinkham, often accompanied by a terrifically talented ensemble performing Lorin Latarro’s dazzling choreography; the singers and dancers are like a glorious symphony that makes you instantly forget the book’s occasional meanderings and messiness. Yes, there are too many songs, Freddie’s transition to being an announcer is annoying, the love triangle is messy, the politics are oversimplified, and the ballads are histrionic, but Mayer and Strong keep the actual chess to a minimum, and every time the show threatens to give in to the lowest common denominator, Pinkham and the ensemble swoop in to rescue it as the endgame approaches.

Chess is nominated for five Tonys: Best Orchestrations, Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical (Christopher), and Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Musical (Pinkham), Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Musical (Cruz), and Best Lighting.

FALLEN ANGELS
Todd Haimes Theatre
227 West 42nd St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Closed June 7
www.roundabouttheatre.org

Rose Byrne and Kelli O’Hara are the most hilarious comedy duo on Broadway in Scott Ellis’s elegant slapstick revival of Noël Coward’s Fallen Angels. When an old Parisian flame (Mark Consuelos) might be coming to town, Julia (O’Hara) and Jane (Byrne) get some interesting ideas while their men (Aasif Mandvi and Christopher Fitzgerald) are away. The Champagne flows, as do their bodies over the furniture, all while the new maid, Saunders (Tracee Chimo), who seems to know everything about everything, keeps a close watch on the proceedings. The story itself may be slight, but in the hands of Byrne and O’Hara, it’s a riot. Oh, and their hair!

Fallen Angels is nominated for five Tonys: Best Revival, Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Play (Byrne, O’Hara), Best Scenic Design, and Best Costume Design.

JOE TURNER’S COME AND GONE
Barrymore Theatre
243 West Forty-Seventh St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Tuesday – Sunday through July 26, $69 – $499
joeturnerbway.com

The fourth play in August Wilson’s Pittsburgh Cycle, Joe Turner’s Come and Gone is set in the 1910s in a boardinghouse run by Seth Holly (Cedric the Entertainer) and his wife, Bertha (Taraji P. Henson). Among the residents are conjure man Bynum Walker (a never-better Ruben Santiago-Hudson) and guitar player and ladies man Jeremy Furlow (Tripp Taylor), while hanging around is people finder Rutherford Selig (Bradley Stryker). When the scary Herald Loomis (Joshua Boone) arrives with his young daughter, Zonia, trying to track down his wife, the past bubbles up, laced with supernatural elements. Joe Turner is another sparkling work by Wilson, a poetic exploration of the lasting impact of slavery and the Great Migration, a tempting mix of humor, music, and history that looks and sounds marvelous on the stage, directed by Debbie Allen.

Joe Turner’s Come and Gone is nominated for five Tonys: Best Original Score, Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Play (Santiago-Hudson), Best Sound, Best Lighting, and Best Costume Design; oddly, it did not make the cut for Best Revival of a Play.

LIBERATION
James Earl Jones Theatre
138 West Forty-Eighth St. between Sixth & Seventh Aves.
Closed February 1
liberationbway.com

In Bess Wohl’s dazzling Liberation: A Memory Play About Things I Don’t Remember, the playwright reimagines her mother’s 1970s consciousness-raising women’s group. The women meet in a rec center basement in Ohio to discuss the role of women in society, how it impacts their lives individually and what they can do to help change the status quo publicly. The concept of the Everywoman takes center stage at the start of the second act, when Lizzie, Margie, Susie, Celeste, Isidora, and Dora remove their clothing and sit in the usual semicircle of folding chairs, as Cha See’s gymnasium lighting keeps them brightly lit so there’s nowhere to hide. One by one, they share intimate details — or opt not to — about their bodies, each one dealing with their nudity in a different way, choosing to proudly reveal or attempt to conceal. The overt nakedness can make the audience, especially the men, uncomfortable, confronting them with questions about their own attitudes. It’s an unforgettable theatrical experience written by one of America’s best playwrights.

Liberation is nominated for five Tonys: Best Play, Best Direction of a Play (Whitney White), Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Play (Susannah Flood), Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Play (Betsy Aidem), and Best Costume Design.

BUG
Samuel J. Friedman Theatre
261 West Forty-Seventh St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Closed March 8
www.manhattantheatreclub.com

It’s been several months since I saw the Broadway debut of Tracy Letts’s Bug, and I’m still feeling all itchy and out of sorts, scratching myself all over, thinking I’m being invaded by tiny killer insects. The show is led by the sizzling hot Carrie Coon, Letts’s wife, who plays Agnes White, a forty-four-year-old woman living in a motel room outside of Oklahoma City. The opening moment is stark and beautiful: Agnes stands near the door, smoking a cigarette and holding a wineglass, looking outside as if the world is not for her. Later she’s having a crack, coke, and booze party with her best friend, the wild R.C. (Jennifer Engstrom), and a guy R.C. just met, a veteran named Peter Evans (Namir Smallwood), who is soon insisting that the room is crawling with dangerous bugs that are immune to standard spray. The play is like the bizarre offspring of Francis Ford Coppola’s brilliant 1974 The Conversation and the 1941 Popeye cartoon Flies Ain’t Human. Bug is a taut, involving thriller, with authentic scares that get under your skin. It will also make you feel genuinely threatened the next time you’re itchy, searching for a creepy crawly creature — or following a military industrial complex conspiracy theory — with an unusual taste for human blood.

Bug is nominated for four Tonys: Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Play (Coon), Best Scenic Design, Best Sound, and Best Lighting.

GIANT
Music Box Theatre
239 West 45th St. between Broadway & Eighth Aves.
Wednesday – Sunday through June 28, $89–$599
gianttheplay.com

Roald Dahl might not be “a beautiful role,” but it is one that John Lithgow performs with delicious relish in Mark Rosenblatt’s first play, Giant. It is as hard to like the character as it is to accept what he says — the show focuses on Dahl’s overt antisemitism, which created a controversy in 1983 that is still relevant today — but speech must be free if it is anything. Aya Cash is a fine foil as a sales director refusing to back down, Elliot Levey is strong as a weak-willed man some would call a self-hating Jew, Rachael Stirling is terrific as a woman caught in the middle of it all, and Stella Everett shines as the house cook who stays out of everything until she can’t. The show is splendidly directed by Sir Nicholas Hytner, maintaining a furious pace and glorying in the English language.

Giant is nominated for four Tonys: Best Play, Best Direction of a Play (Hytner), Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Play (Lithgow), and Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Play (Cash).

TITANIQUE
St. James Theatre
246 West Forty-Fourth St. between Broadway & Eighth Aves.
Tuesday – Sunday through September 20, $69.44-$879.63
titaniquebroadway.com

In September 2022, I wrote, “I couldn’t help but fall under the bewitching spell of Titanique, a wild and wooly musical parody of the beloved 1997 weepie shipwreck rom-com,” after seeing the DIY show at the downstairs Asylum Theatre. While its transfer to Broadway isn’t quite a disaster, it doesn’t come close to the joy and energy it had underground. Much of its original charm was its “Let’s put on a show” atmosphere, but as soon as the curtain rose at the St. James, my mouth dropped, sad that it is now a big-budget extravaganza. It still is fun, led by stellar performances by cocreator Constantine Rousouli as Jack Dawson and Melissa Barrera as Rose DeWitt Bukater, but Jim Parsons overplays Ruth, cocreator Marla Mindelle is too cutesy as host Céline Dion, and too many of the nonstop inside jokes and modern references fall flat.

Titanique is nominated for four Tonys: Best Musical, Best Book, Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical (Mindelle), and Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Musical (Layton Williams).

DOG DAY AFTERNOON
August Wilson Theatre
245 West Fifty-Second St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Tuesday – Sunday through July 12, $57.12-$418.88
dogdayafternoon.com

Jessica Hecht is wonderful as chief bank teller Colleen in Stephen Adly Guirgis and Rupert Goold’s adaptation of Sidney Lumet’s classic 1975 based-on-fact crime thriller about a bank robbery gone terribly wrong, which also applies to this production. Jon Bernthal and Ebon Moss-Bachrach, costars on The Bear, had been wanting to take the film to Broadway for a long time, but unfortunately it still needs more work. Bernthal is Sonny, famously played by Al Pacino in the movie, who decides to rob a Brooklyn bank in order to raise money for his lover’s (Esteban Andres Cruz) sex-change operation. His cohorts are Ray Ray (Christopher Sears), who has a meltdown, and the absurdly jumpy Sal (Moss-Bachrach, taking on John Cazale’s unforgettable part), who seems to have a happy trigger finger. John Ortiz is fine as the detective attempting to bring them in, but Spencer Garrett misfires as FBI Agent Sheldon. (I can only imagine what Matthew Broderick, who was sitting two rows in front of me, was thinking, as his father, James, was superb as the FBI agent in the film.) Too much happens off the cool set, and as the play goes on, Bernthal becomes more and more like Pacino, except he is unable to whip up excitement in the crowd watching him.

Dog Day Afternoon is nominated for three Tonys: Best Scenic Design, Best Costume design, and Best Lighting.

BECKY SHAW
Hayes Theater
240 West 44th St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Tuesday – Sunday through June 14, $154 – $347
2st.com

Alden Ehrenreich plays one of the all-time biggest assholes in the Broadway debut of Gina Gionfriddo’s extremely funny dark comedy about family dysfunction, empathy, and how we care for one another — or don’t, all beginning with a blind date that goes terribly wrong. David Zinn’s gorgeous sets are enhanced by the activity that takes place during scene changes; be sure to pay close attention! Also in the outstanding cast are Patrick Ball, Madeline Brewer, Linda Emond, and Lauren Patten. This one is a gem, directed with acerbic wit by Trip Cullman.

Becky Shaw is nominated for two Tonys but deserved many more: Best Revival and Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Play (Ehrenreich).

EVERY BRILLIANT THING
Hudson Theatre
141 West Forty-Fourth St. between Sixth & Seventh Aves.
Tuesday – Sunday through January 4, $62.72-$301.28
everybrilliantthing.com

I previously saw the sixty-five-minute Every Brilliant Thing at the Barrow Street Theatre in March 2015, starring Jonny Donahoe, who gets a smaller-font writing credit with the larger-font Duncan Macmillan. George Perrin directed that version, but the Broadway iteration is helmed by Macmillan and Jeremy Herrin. Be sure to arrive early, because when the doors open, the star (originally Daniel Radcliffe, but now Mariska Hargitay, to be followed by Tracee Ellis Ross) is roaming around the theater, handing out prompts and speaking with various audience members, both in the regular seating as well as three rows of rafters on the stage. They are looking for people to call out items from a list and to play several important roles in the character’s life. The narrator re-creates scenes from the past, all involving the audience in one way or another. The success of the play depends on the audience members’ performances and the narrator’s ability to improvise if things don’t go quite as expected; the night I went, both were in top form. Through it all, Macmillan and Donahoe explore the fragile nature of depression and suicide, from how families deal with mental illness to the hyper-controlled way it’s depicted in the media. Every Brilliant Thing is essentially about making connections, both in life and in theater, being part of something that is bigger than yourself. It’s tragedy and comedy of the highest order, an unforgettable experience that just might lead to your jotting down some of the things that make your life worth living. And the first one is very likely to be: Every Brilliant Thing.

Every Brilliant Thing is nominated for two Tonys: Best Revival and Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Play (Radcliffe).

THE FEAR OF 13
James Earl Jones Theatre
138 West Forty-Eighth St. between Sixth & Seventh Aves.
Tuesday – Sunday through July 12, $51-$299
thefearof13broadway.com

The excitement was palpable for the Broadway debuts of two-time Oscar winner Adrien Brody and Tessa Thompson in Lindsey Ferrentino’s The Fear of 13, directed by the great David Cromer, but I’m afraid the based-on-fact prison drama never breaks out. Brody plays Nick Yarris, who is on death row for a crime he might not have committed. He is befriended by Jacki Miles (Thompson), a regular visitor reaching out to incarcerated men but she develops an intimate bond with Nick, who at first seems resigned to eventually being executed. Brody and Thompson do have an affecting chemistry, but the show is too long at 110 minutes, it often feels convoluted even though it’s true, there are extraneous scenes, and it never makes a connection with the audience.

The Fear of 13 is nominated for two Tonys: Best Lighting and Best Sound.

MARJORIE PRIME
Hayes Theater
240 West 44th St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Closed February 15
2st.com

“Age will be no obstacle,” Jon (Danny Burstein) reads from an old love letter in the Broadway premiere of Jordan Harrison’s Marjorie Prime. The play, adroitly directed by Anne Kauffman, stars ninety-six-year-old June Squibb as the title character, an eighty-six-year-old woman who lives with her daughter, Tess (Cynthia Nixon), son-in-law, Jon, and an AI version of her late husband, Walter Prime (Christopher Lowell), who leads Marjorie through carefully selected — and edited — memories, from their early dates to watching their dog run on the beach, all while avoiding one particular horrific family tragedy. The prime begins its existence as a blank slate; it merely processes whatever information it has been fed. Harrison refers to the physical reincarnations as “descendants of the current chatbots.” When Marjorie dies, Tess has to decide whether she wants to turn her mother into a prime and have her AI program, and Walter’s, keep living with them. The play debuted in 2014 and was made into a film in 2017; as far as aging goes, it already feels out of date as the AI boom explodes nearly every day, detracting from its impact. However, the ending is absolutely brilliant.

Marjorie Prime is nominated for two Tonys: Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Play (Burstein) and Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Play (Squibb).

LITTLE BEAR RIDGE ROAD
Booth Theatre
222 West 45th St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Closed December 21
littlebearridgeroad.com

For me, the biggest disappointment of the year in theater is the early closing of Samuel D. Hunter’s sensational Little Bear Ridge Road. Originally scheduled to run until February 14, it is instead closing December 21, after opening on October 30 to a bevy of rave reviews. The play is a gripping ninety-five minutes of nonstop tension, brilliantly directed by two-time Tony winner Joe Mantello on Scott Pask’s beautifully minimalist set. On a couch on a round, carpeted platform, Sarah (Laurie Metcalf) and her nephew, Ethan (Micah Stock), spend a lot of time watching TV and complaining about their lives following the passing of Sarah’s brother, Ethan’s estranged father, a drug addict who died a miserable death. The narrative takes place between 2020 and 2022, and the pandemic plays a key role in how characters interact with each other, whether out at a bar or sitting home watching television, especially Extraterrestrial. Heather Gilbert’s intimate lighting is exceptional, making the audience feel like it’s on the couch, hanging out with Sarah, Ethan, and James. It’s a fabulous Broadway debut for Hunter; I apologize for all the superlatives, but each one is well deserved. Not only did it close early, but it received a mere single nod for Best Play, with no love for any of the myriad elements that made it so special.

Little Bear Ridge Road is nominated for one Tony: Best Play, which apparently got there without any worthy elements.

PUNCH
Samuel J. Friedman Theatre
261 West Forty-Seventh St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Closed November 2
www.manhattantheatreclub.com

Will Harrison makes an electrifying Broadway debut as a young Nottingham man whose life changes forever on a wild night in James Graham’s Punch. Harrison stars as Jacob in the true story, based on the memoir Right from Wrong by Jacob Dunne, which explores bullying, drugs, class, and restorative justice. One night, nineteen-year-old Jacob and his large gang of friends are out drinking and snorting as they barhop through Nottingham, Jacob in search of some action; he finds it when he unleashes a massive punch on a random stranger just for kicks, but when the young man, twenty-eight-year-old James Hodgkinson, dies as a result of the altercation, Jacob is sent to prison while James’s parents, David Hodgkinson (Sam Robards) and Joan Scourfield (Victoria Clark), deal with the tragic loss of their son and contemplate whether they should forgive Jacob. The energetic, fast-paced first act shifts between the punch and its immediate aftermath and a group therapy session led by Sandra (Lucy Taylor, who also plays Jacob’s mother and a probation officer), where Jacob shares his story with others. Sandra describes it as a place for “talking and listening. Difficult conversations.” Those conversations center on restorative justice, as Jacob, Joan, and David decide if they are going to meet face-to-face. The second half is decidedly slower and less compelling, but you can’t take your eyes off Harrison, a rising star with a bright future.

Punch is nominated for one Tony: Best Performance by a Leading Actor in a Play (Harrison).

WAITING FOR GODOT
Hudson Theatre
141 West Forty-Fourth St. between Sixth & Seventh Aves.
Closed January 4
godotbroadway.com

Last fall, the talk of the town was Keanu Reeves and Alex Winter reprising — well, channeling? — their roles from 1989’s Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure and the 1991 and 2020 sequels in Waiting for Godot at the Hudson Theatre. Action star Reeves was making his Broadway debut as Estragon (Gogo) in Jamie Lloyd’s bumpy adaptation, while Winter returned to the Great White Way for the first time in forty-four years as Vladimir (Didi). For the most part, they hold the audience’s attention. Gogo and Didi usually find themselves in a strange, dark wasteland, with only a single bare tree, a country road, and a solitary stone as they contemplate life and death, heaven and hell, and existence and humanity, but Lloyd and set designer Soutra Gilmour locate them inside a giant tube that is part tunnel, part circular skateboard ramp, part existential void in space. Resembling abandoned vaudevillians in all black, sporting impressive bowlers (the costumes are also by Gilmour), they sit at the edge of the tube, feet dangling, waiting for the mysterious Godot to arrive and, perhaps, bring meaning to their sad, pathetic lives. Reeves and Winter may not display a wide range of emotions, but they avail themselves well enough to keep the audience engaged. At one point Didi says, “This is not boring you I hope,” looking out at us, and we essentially answer no.

Waiting for Godot is nominated for one Tony: Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Play (Brandon J. Dirden).

ART
Music Box Theatre
239 West 45th St. between Broadway & Eighth Aves.
Closed December 21
artonbroadway.com

One of my favorite theatrical moments of 2025 occurred at the end of the matinee of Art I attended. As the curtain closed, James Corden gave a little hop, skip, and jump, grabbing onto the shoulders of his two costars, Bobby Cannavale and Neil Patrick Harris, as a wide, childlike smile broke out across his face. It was one of the most happy-making things I’d seen all year. It made the whole experience that much more enjoyable, helping me forget some of the holes in what is a pleasurable if not nearly as deep as it wants to be show. What are these men doing in Paris? Were they ever really close friends? Can Marc (Cannavale) and Serge (Harris) just leave poor Yvan (Corden) alone already? When the audience enters the Music Box Theatre, they are greeted by a framed white rectangle on the red curtain, not only representing the white painting that Serge has paid three hundred thousand dollars for, but also the blank slate we all come into the world with, onto which we project our personal likes and dislikes, including how we appreciate, or don’t, art itself. When the play is over, some will have loved it, some will have despised it, and other, perhaps most, will find themselves in between. Friends will defend their views, just as Serge defends his purchase to Marc, who is insulted that Serge spent so much money on a white canvas, while Yvan is caught in the middle.

Art received no Tony nominations.

BEACHES
Majestic Theatre
247 West 44th St. between Broadway & Eighth Aves.
Closed May 24
beachesthemusical.com

Directors Lonny Price and Matt Cowart’s Broadway musical adaptation of the beloved 1988 film about female friendship starring Bette Midler and Barbara Hershey is all washed up. Novel author Iris Rainer Dart wrote the drab book with Thom Thomas and penned the drab lyrics, and the drab music is by Mike Stoller. While the first act mostly works, as Bertie (Zeya Grace) and Cee Cee (Samantha Schwartz) meet as kids on the Atlantic City boardwalk, as they grow up, the narrative goes all over the place, the songs are unmemorable, and the plot untenable. Jessica Vosk does some heavy lifting as the adult Cee Cee, while Kelli Barrett has less to do as the mature Bertie. I can’t recall a single major dance number, although a choreographer is listed on the program. There’s just not enough wind beneath these wings.

Beaches received no Tony nominations.

CALL ME IZZY
Studio 54
254 West 54th St. between Seventh & Eighth Aves.
Closed August 17
callmeizzyplay.com

Baton Rouge native Jamie Wax’s debut play, Call Me Izzy, is a darkly funny and insightful one-person drama, an exploration of an all-too-familiar topic: domestic abuse. Although it borders on clichéd situations and flirts with poverty porn, it never tips over the edge. The stellar production, directed by Sarna Lapine and anchored by an exquisite performance by six-time Emmy winner and Tony and Grammy nominee Jean Smart, makes it much more. In a triumphant return to Broadway after nearly twenty-five years, Smart portrays Isabelle Scutley, née Fontenot, a woman living with her brutish husband, a pipe fitter named Ferd, in a mobile home in the fictional Louisiana Lady Trailer Park in the real town of Mansfield, Louisiana. Telling her story directly to the audience, Isabelle, who was married at seventeen and got a cemetery plot as a wedding present from her husband, has been trying to establish her own identity since she was a child, but under societal constraints and Ferd’s firm thumb she has rarely had a true sense of self. An aspiring poet, she asks, “If you write something and no one ever reads it, does it even exist? Do I exist? Do you exist?” Lapine keeps things moving smoothly through the play’s hundred minutes, but the show belongs to Smart, who has the rapturous audience behind her every step of the way. At the matinee I saw, applause broke out after numerous scenes not just for Smart’s acting talent but for choices Izzy makes.

Call Me Izzy received no Tony nominations.

PROOF
Booth Theatre
222 West 45th St. between Broadway & Eighth Ave.
Tuesday – Sunday through July 19, $58 – $297
proofbroadway.com

In 2001, David Auburn’s Proof won the Pulitzer Prize and Tonys for Best Play and Best Director (Daniel Sullivan), and all four cast members were nominated, with Mary-Louise Parker taking home the award for Best Actress. Watching Thomas Kail’s revival, there’s no evidence was to what all the hubbub was about. Don Cheadle stars as Robert, a deceased genius mathematician with severe mental illness who still talks to his genius daughter, Catherine (Ayo Edebiri), who is stuck in a rut. Her sister, Claire (Kara Young), is trying to reach out, and one of her father’s former students, Hal (Jin Ha), wants to go through Robert’s notebook in the hopes of finding something publishable. Numerous times, Catherine is asked how she’s doing, and she answers, “fine.” And that’s what this show is, merely fine. And oh, that interstitial music.

Proof received no Tony nominations.

THE QUEEN OF VERSAILLES
St. James Theatre
246 West Forty-Fourth St. between Broadway & Eighth Aves.
Tuesday – Sunday through December 21, $88.48-$441.28
queenofversaillesmusical.com

It’s never fun writing a review for a show that is closing early; it’s sort of like that old saying, Don’t speak ill of the dead. When I went to the St. James Theatre to see The Queen of Versailles, a musical based on the hit documentary, I was fully prepared to find something to like about it despite all the negative chatter that was circulating. And indeed, I thoroughly enjoyed the first scene, which takes place in Paris in 1661, as Louis XIV (Pablo David Laucerica) is getting ready to move to his new home in Versailles. I also was all in on the second scene, with the action moving to Florida in 2006, where Jackie Siegel (Kristin Chenoweth) is overseeing the construction of her own Versailles with her fabulously wealthy, much older husband, David (F. Murray Abraham). After that, well, I just couldn’t. The story devolves quickly into tawdry melodrama, along with clunky staging and less-than-compelling musical numbers. The book, which refuses to decide whether Jackie is a strong woman, a greedy socialite, or a misunderstood wife and mother, is by Olivier nominee Lindsey Ferrentino, the director is Tony winner Michael Arden, and the music and lyrics are by Oscar winner Stephen Schwartz, all of whom should have known better.

The Queen of Versailles received no Tony nominations.

[Mark Rifkin is a Brooklyn-born, Manhattan-based writer and editor; you can follow him on Substack here.]