this week in theater

TUESDAYS WITH MORRIE

Chris Domig and Len Cariou star in touching revival of Tuesdays with Morrie (photo by Jeremy Varner)

TUESDAYS WITH MORRIE
St. George’s Episcopal Church
209 East Sixteenth St. at Rutherford Pl.
Through March 23, $20-$55
www.seadogtheater.org

“I never give advice,” Morrie Schwartz tells Mitch Albom in Tuesdays with Morrie.

Maybe not, but nearly everything that comes out of his mouth are words to live by — and die by.

Albom’s Tuesdays with Morrie, the true story of the friendship between sports reporter Albom and Brandeis professor Schwartz, started as a 1997 book, subtitled An Old Man, a Young Man, and Life’s Greatest Lesson. Mick Jackson turned it into a popular 1999 film, starring Jack Lemmon as Schwartz and Hank Azaria as Albom. It won four Emmys, including Outstanding Made for Television Movie, and put the memoir at the top of the bestseller list for a combined twenty-three weeks. In November 2002, Albom and Jeffrey Hatcher adapted the book into an off-Broadway play directed by Obie winner David Esbjornson.

The show is now back in a warm, intimate revival from Sea Dog Theater running in the long, narrow chantry at St. George’s Episcopal Church through March 23, anchored by two wonderful performances.

As the audience enters the space, Mitch (Chris Domig) is sitting behind a grand piano at the center of the room, playing jazz tunes. After a few songs, Morrie (Len Cariou) enters, joining Mitch on the piano bench and enjoying the music. The play proper soon begins, with Mitch directly addressing the audience, telling us about a college class he had taken with Morrie called “The Meaning of Life.” Mitch, the only student, remembers, “There was no required reading, but many topics were covered: love, work, aging, family, community, forgiveness . . . and death.” Those are the same topics covered in the play.

Mitch, who is thirty-seven, and Morrie, who is seventy-eight, switch back and forth between talking to the audience and reenacting scenes from their past together. Mitch took all of Morrie’s classes at Brandeis; the two became fast friends, with Mitch calling his mentor “Coach.” When Mitch graduates in 1979, he promises to keep in touch, but sixteen years pass with no contact, until he sees his old teacher on Nightline, explaining to Ted Koppel that he has ALS, or Lou Gehrig’s disease. Feeling guilty, Mitch goes to see Morrie; when his teacher asks him what happened, Mitch responds, “Life happened.”

What Mitch thought would be a one-time visit becomes a weekly event, and Mitch begins recording his Tuesday discussions with Morrie, who has found it somewhat surprising that people are so interested in him now. “I’m not quite alive, I’m not quite dead, I’m ‘in-between,’” he says. “I’m about to take that last journey into the great unknown. People want to know what to pack.”

Morrie might not ever give advice, but he speaks in memorable aphorisms that avoid being overly treacly:

“Dying is only one thing to be sad over. Living unhappily is something else.”

“Why be predictable?”

“Aging is not just decay . . . . A tree’s leaves are most colorful just before they die.”

“Age is not a competition.”

“There’s no ‘point’ in loving; loving is the point.”

Mitch (Chris Domig) worries about his dying friend, Morrie (Len Cariou), in Tuesdays with Morrie (photo by Jeremy Varner)

The two men share stories from their lives, delving into career choices, music, romantic partners, parents, and children. Initially, Mitch is tentative and anxious, regularly on his phone as he prepares for his next column, interview, or television appearance. He does slow down a bit as Morrie grows more and more ill, the end approaching, which makes Mitch more sad than Morrie. Mitch might have told us early on, “I don’t need a ‘life therapist,’” but he is learning so much from Coach — and so are we.

Tuesdays with Morrie feels right at home in St. George’s, even as it features two Jewish characters; Guy DeLancey’s set and lighting center around the piano and cast glows on the pillars, and Eamon Goodman’s sound, from the dialogue to actor and composer Domig’s expert keyboard playing to a snippet of a pop standard, are never lost in the high-ceilinged room over the course of the play’s easygoing hundred minutes.

Tony winner and Emmy nominee Cariou (Sweeney Todd, A Little Night Music) is gentle and touching as Morrie; at eighty-four, Cariou has both the stage and the life experience, and it shows in his every gesture and turn of phrase. You can’t help but love being in his presence, as actor and character.

Domig, the cofounder of Sea Dog Theater, is terrific as the self-involved, super-ambitious Mitch, who has never stopped and smelled the roses. Domig is almost too nice; Morrie tells Mitch that he can be “mean-spirited,” something I noticed while watching Albom for several years on the Sunday morning ESPN program The Sports Reporters. Cariou and Domig also dodge around some of the more clichéd and melodramatic aspects of the script with the help of director Erwin Maas; the trio has spent a lot of time working together on the project, beginning with a reading at St. George’s in 2021, and they clearly have developed an infectious camaraderie.

“Are you at peace with yourself?” Morrie asks Mitch.

After seeing this adaptation of Tuesdays with Morrie, your answer will be a lot clearer.

[Mark Rifkin is a Brooklyn-born, Manhattan-based writer and editor; you can follow him on Substack here.]

THE CONNECTOR

The Connector takes place at a New York City magazine publisher in the mid-1990s (photo by Joan Marcus)

THE CONNECTOR
The Robert W. Wilson MCC Theater Space
511 West Fifty-Second St. between Tenth & Eleventh Aves.
Tuesday – Sunday through March 17, $74-$139
mcctheater.org

Beowulf Boritt’s set is the star of The Connector, an otherwise hit-or-miss new musical conceived and directed by Daisy Prince, with a book by Jonathan Marc Sherman and music and lyrics by Tony winner Jason Robert Brown.

The show takes place in the offices of a well-respected magazine called the Connector. On the back wall is a rectangular grid of more than one hundred folded-over magazine spreads on which lighting designer Jeanette Oi-Suk Yew projects various images in addition to, for one fabulous scene, a Scrabble board; neon lights form multiple shapes in different colors on the black floor, also a grid. Off to the sides are mounds and mounds of paper. Tables, desks, and chairs are wheeled on an off to indicate trips to different offices and outdoors.

The magazine is run by Conrad O’Brien (Scott Bakula), who is determined to continue the legacy of the magazine’s founder, Aubrey Bernard, who started the Connector in 1946. It’s 1996, and the conglomerate VorschlagXE are their new partners. When enthusiastic young journalist Ethan Dobson (Ben Levi Ross) arrives, O’Brien is immediately impressed by the recent college grad and gives him a job. It isn’t long before Dobson is getting major stories published in the magazine, much to the chagrin of assistant copy editor Robin Martinez (Hannah Cruz), whose pieces keep getting rejected by O’Brien, and Tom Henshaw (Fergie Philippe), a dependable but unexciting writer.

As Dobson’s stories become more and more popular, fact checker Muriel (Jessica Molaskey) has more and more questions, as does loyal Connector reader Mona Bland (Mylinda Hull), who regularly sends in letters to the editor with praise and criticism, and Martinez, who is suspicious of how Dobson is writing so many articles so quickly.

Ethan Dobson’s first story is about the prowess of Scrabble mastermind Waldo Pine (Max Crumm) (photo by Joan Marcus)

The Connector was inspired by the fraud perpetrated by Stephen Glass at the New Republic in 1998. Much of the show rings true, but just as much doesn’t. From 2001 to 2004, I served as editor in chief of a free local New York City newsmagazine with a small staff, consisting of a news editor, a features editor, and a managing editor. We all proofread and fact-checked one another’s articles as best we could, right at the time that use of the internet exploded around the country. I just find it too difficult to buy how easily O’Brien falls under the spell of the overly cocky and annoying Dobson, ignoring all the warning signs, even as he is distracted by VorschlagXE executive Veronica (Ann Sanders).

One of the show’s aims is to relate its plot to the fake news that now dominates social media and overtly biased television programs and publications, but the connection doesn’t come through. When O’Brien makes a toast early on, proclaiming, “To our fabled history of writers and editors, who still search, reach, and fight for the truth. To our beloved, well-educated, politically active readers,” it’s as if they are already outliers, ill-prepared for what is to come. “Together, we shall thrive and grow for many more decades, pushing forward, staying true to the tenets Aubrey Bernard held so dear!” he adds.

The Connector is a musical, but it feels much more like a play with musical scenes, never quite cohering as a whole. Karla Puno Garcia’s choreography ranges from barely there in the introductory number to fun and fanciful in Waldo’s celebration to head scratching during Dobson’s visit to the Western Wall in Jerusalem. Brown’s (Parade, The Last Five Years) arrangements and orchestrations crackle, but the songs, performed by a small band behind the backdrop, lack consistency as they go from ballads to hip-hop to klezmer. Director Prince, who has previously helmed Brown’s The Last Five Years and Songs for a New World, is unable to get the scenes to smoothly flow into each other. And while there are laughs, a pair of cheap shots at Texas and New Jersey in “So I Came to New York” linger badly.

Ethan (Ben Levi Ross) and Robin (Hannah Cruz) become friends and rivals in The Connector (photo by Joan Marcus)

Bakula (Three Guys Naked from the Waist Down, Guys and Dolls), who was nominated for a Tony as Best Leading Actor in a Musical for 1988’s Romance/Romance, has a firm grasp of his character in his return to the New York stage, while Cruz (Only Gold, Suffs) excels as Martinez, Molaskey (A Man of No Importance, Sunday in the Park with George) is right on point as the fussy Muriel, and Crumm (Emojiland, Disaster!) nearly steals the show as Waldo.

The cast also includes Daniel Jenkins as Connector lawyer Zachary, Michael Winther as cable host Brian Lamb, Danielle Lee Greaves as Jersey City mayoral aide Sheryl Hughes, Ashley Pérez Flanagan as copy editor Florencia Moreno, and Eliseo Román as Nestor Fineman, the fictional head of the real-life New York Press, which was the archrival of the publication I ran twenty-plus years ago.

In the end, The Connector has some worthwhile articles but could use more editing to cut down on the excess.

[Mark Rifkin is a Brooklyn-born, Manhattan-based writer and editor; you can follow him on Substack here.]

THE HUNT

Tobias Menzies stars as a man accused of a horrible crime in The Hunt (photo by Teddy Wolff)

THE HUNT
St. Ann’s Warehouse
45 Water St.
Tuesday – Sunday through March 24, $64-$84
718-254-8779
stannswarehouse.org

In 2012, St. Ann’s Warehouse presented the US premiere of Grzegorz Jarzyna’s mesmerizing adaptation of Thomas Vinterberg and Tobias Lindholm’s 1998 Dogme 95 film, Festen (The Celebration), about a birthday party at which the adult son of the honoree suddenly accuses his father of having sexually abused him and his twin sister when they were children.

That same year, Danish writer-director Vinterberg released his terrifying Oscar-nominated drama Jagten (The Hunt), in which Mads Mikkelsen stars as a kindergarten teacher falsely accused of sexually abusing a six-year-old student in a small, tight-knit town.

Writer David Farr and director Rupert Goold’s adaptation of The Hunt for the Almeida Theatre is now having its US premiere at St. Ann’s; it’s a haunting tale of hunters and their prey.

Tobias Menzies makes a dazzling US stage debut as Lucas Bruun, a forty-year-old educator who is teaching at the Sunbeam Infants School in an isolated village in Northern Denmark after his previous employer closed. He has separated from his wife, Susanne, and is frustrated that he is not getting enough time to spend with their sixteen-year-old son, Marcus (Raphael Casey).

A teacher (Tobias Menzies) is given a surprise present by one of his students (Aerina DeBoer) in The Hunt (photo by Teddy Wolff)

After a special event, his favorite student, five-year-old Clara Kallstrom (alternately played by Aerina DeBoer or Kay Winard), tells school head Hilde (Lolita Chakrabarti) that Lucas exposed himself to her, which is not true. Soon the entire town, including Clara’s parents, Mikala (MyAnna Buring) and Theo (Alex Hassell), who are Lucas’s closest friends, has turned against him, branding him a pariah.

Curiously, as his world crumbles around him, the fiercely private Lucas doesn’t stand up for himself, never proclaiming his innocence, even though we saw the encounter in question and know he did not do anything wrong. He begs the school and Clara’s parents to let him talk to the girl in order to straighten everything out, but no one wants him near her or the school. Even his buddies in the Men of the Lodge, a group of hunters who love singing, shooting, and boozing it up, immediately ostracize him, making him the hunted. The only support he receives is from his dog, Max, and Marcus, who shows up unexpectedly at his doorstep.

“Talking to you is like scaling a fucking castle wall. You know that?” Mikala tells him.

But he’s not about to let anyone in, even with his life in danger.

The Hunt takes place on Es Devlin’s fascinating set, a house-shaped cube that switches from transparent to opaque in a flash; it rests on a turntable, so it occasionally spins, and there is a trapdoor so characters can appear and disappear. Neil Austin’s lighting includes neon lines on the floor, ceiling, and wall and in and on the cube itself, while Adam Cork’s sound is highlighted by songbirds who represent the freedom that is just out of Lucas’s reach.

Despite the plentiful open space, the cube gives the show a claustrophobic feeling, whether it’s being used as a church or the men’s lodge, stuffed with people, or for a lone antlered forest creature signaling potential doom.

Es Devlin’s set is a character unto itself in US premiere of Almeida production at St. Ann’s (photo by Teddy Wolff)

Ritual and social convention hover over the narrative. The show opens with Hilde directly addressing the audience, introducing the children’s harvest festival play. “Welcome, everyone. It’s lovely to see so many familiar faces,” she says. “We are a small community. The happiness of our children is everything. Our hopes and dreams rest in these tiny souls. And to spend each day with them is a kind of heaven.”

In the next scene, the Men of the Lodge are in bathing suits, going for a manly swim, belting out, “Oh, eight men they go swimming / In the water oh so cold / The eight men they are hunters / The eight men they are bold / The eight men they are heroes / They never will grow old / Their bodies made of iron / Their hearts are made of gold / The hunters undefeated / Are mighty to behold. They dance in unison to Kel Matsena’s testosterone-filled choreography, which takes a darker path as Christmas approaches.

Emmy winner Menzies, best known in America for his roles on Outlander and The Crown, is riveting as Lucas, a highly principled man who has too much faith in others. He remains soft-spoken even as his freedom is being stolen. Buring and Hassell excel as Lucas’s best friends, who are not sure what or whom to believe. The rest of the ensemble is strong, including Chakrabarti as the school head whose job it is to protect the children, Casey as the son who has faith in his father, Howard Ward as a school administrator and the local pastor, Rumi C. Jean-Louis or Christopher Riley as Clara’s school pal Peter, and Adrian Der Gregorian, Ali Goldsmith, Shaquille Jack, Danny Kirrane, and Jonathan Savage as the other Men of the Lodge.

Farr (Night Manager, The Homecoming) and Goold (Patriots, Ink) occasionally stray from the film’s story, with uneven results; a few scenes are awkward, but they right the ship for a poignant finale.

At two points, characters suddenly appear at the back of the audience and make their way to the stage, as if any one of us could be them. Would we be the accused, the accuser, or the townspeople who have to look deep inside themselves? None will like what they find.

[Mark Rifkin is a Brooklyn-born, Manhattan-based writer and editor; you can follow him on Substack here.]

TALKING BAND: EXISTENTIALISM

Husband-and-wife Ellen Maddow and Paul Zimet portray a married couple in Existentialism (photo by Maria Baranova)

EXISTENTIALISM
La MaMa Experimental Theatre Club
The Ellen Stewart Theatre
66 East Fourth St. between Second Ave. & Bowery
Wednesday – Sunday through March 10, $35-$40
212-475-7710
www.lamama.org
talkingband.org

Early on in Talking Band’s gorgeously poetic two-character play Existentialism, the man says, “Choice is possible. / What is impossible is not to choose. / If I decide not to choose, / That still constitutes a choice.”

It would be a mistake not to choose to see one of the best shows of the year.

Existentialism is created and directed by former SITI Company head Anne Bogart specifically for Ellen Maddow and Paul Zimet in celebration of the fiftieth anniversary of Talking Band, the troupe Maddow and Zimet cofounded with Tina Shepard in 1974. The duo, who have been married since 1986, portray an unnamed woman and man living in a home on the beach. Anna Kiraly’s set features a pair of house-shaped structures, open in the front, each with the same overhead lamp and a small table with a backless chair and typewriter. Short walkways lead out of and around the rooms, with a small planting bed on the woman’s side. Brian Scott’s lighting casts warm red, yellow, orange, blue, and green glows on the structures, while Darron L West’s sound ranges from loud music to soft nature elements to the actors’ crystal-clear enunciations. Kiraly’s projections of waves on the shore and birds flying freely come and go on a large screen in the back.

The woman waters her plants with panache, raising the watering can high above her as the liquid drips out. She does the shopping and is agonized by a speck of dirt she cannot get clean on the path. The two sit at their respective desks on opposite sides of a wall and type in unison.

He saunters to the front of the stage and speaks directly to the audience: “There is a wall between us, but it is a wall we build together. Each of us puts a stone in the gap left by the other. / I’m going to smile, and my smile will sink down into your pupils, and heaven knows what it will become,” he says, sharing an intimate, funny smile. “I am no longer sure of anything. / Something has to snap. / Words are loaded pistols. / There may be more beautiful times, but this one is ours.” Throughout the show’s seventy minutes, we all fill the gaps with figurative stones (and smiles) of our own.

The dialogue is based on the writings of life partners Simone de Beauvoir and Jean-Paul Sartre in addition to Albert Camus, Martin Heidegger, Maurice Merleau-Ponty, Sarah Bakewell, Maggie Nelson, Octavia Butler, bell hooks, and Betty Friedan. The words form an enticing and gentle meditation on gender and aging, delivered in a soft, plain-spoken, but not dispassionate style. The text is all the more compelling because Maddow is seventy-five and Zimet eighty-one; however, they are imbued with an infectious youthfulness.

“My life is set within a given space of time: / It has a beginning and an end, / It evolves in given places, / Always retaining the same roots, / It spins an unchangeable past, / Its future is limited,” the woman says. “No one else is as old as I am. / How young everyone is!”

The man says, “I was young once.”

The man turns on the radio and listens to Dave Brubeck’s “Broadway Bossa Nova” and Beethoven’s “Moonlight Sonata.” The duo dances to the Jim Carroll Band’s punk anthem “People Who Died” blasting out of the speakers, a furious song about how more than a dozen men and women meet untimely ends. “They were all my friends and they died,” Carroll belts out. A New York City native, Carroll himself died of a heart attack in 2009 at the age of sixty; his most well known works include the novel The Basketball Diaries and the LP Catholic Boy.

Time moves on, but the man and the woman continue their daily existence, discussing life in abstract terms.

“No one will ever make sense of this mystery,” she says.

Paul Zimet and Ellen Maddow take a spin in Existentialism (photo by Maria Baranova)

Last month Maddow and Zimet appeared in The Following Evening at PAC NYC, a show written and directed specifically for them by Abigail Browde and Michael Silverstone of 600 Highwaymen, two married creators in their early forties paying tribute to the older couple and what they have accomplished both personally and professionally.

With Existentialism, Bogart is also celebrating Maddow and Zimet. Bogart last worked with Talking Band in 1988, winning the first of her three Obies for directing No Plays No Poetry but Philosophical Reflections Practical Instructions Provocative Prescriptions Opinions and Pointers from a Noted Critic and Playwright, incorporating the writings of Bertolt Brecht; Maddow and Zimet were part of an ensemble cast that also included Louise Smith and Shepard. Bogart has said that when Maddow and Zimet suggested they work together again, she instantly knew it would be called Existentialism; it’s a fitting title for the show, which has its own built-in meta.

Maddow and Zimet are utterly charming in this new piece, which continues at La MaMa through March 10. Although not much is revealed about their characters, you can’t help but fall in love with their relationship. They know they are in the sunset of their lives, but that isn’t stopping them from enjoying every moment. “Do you think that I count the days? There is only one day left, always starting over. It is given to us at dawn and taken away from us at dusk,” he says.

Bogart captures the essence of long-term love, with all its bumps and bruises. When the woman hides behind the wall, listening intently to the man typing away, you can feel how much they adore and need each other. It’s a tender moment that I won’t soon forget.

But right in front of the houses is a rectangular gap in the walkway, a small but constant threat, reminding us how easy it is to fall off one’s path, something Bogart, Maddow, and Zimet don’t have to worry about with this wonderful collaboration.

“Why do we even exist? Hahaha . . . ,” the woman asks. One reasonable answer could be so we could experience such shows as Existentialism.

[Mark Rifkin is a Brooklyn-born, Manhattan-based writer and editor; you can follow him on Substack here.]

THE SEVEN YEAR DISAPPEAR

Taylor Trensch and Cynthia Nixon star in The Seven Year Disappear at the Signature (photo by Monique Carboni)

THE SEVEN YEAR DISAPPEAR
The New Group at the Pershing Square Signature Center
The Alice Griffin Jewel Box Theatre
480 West 42nd St. between between Ninth & Tenth Aves.
Tuesday – Saturday through March 31, $37-$72
thenewgroup.org

I’m a performance art junkie. Throw in some inventive video and I’m even more hooked. But not even those two elements could save me from the train wreck that is The Seven Year Disappear.

As the audience enters the Alice Griffin Jewel Box Theatre at the Pershing Square Signature Center for the New Group world premiere of Jordan Seavey’s play, Cynthia Nixon and Taylor Trensch are silently but intently staring at each other from opposite sides of a long table, wearing dark, militaryesque jumpsuits, surrounded by more than half a dozen monitors. A timeline crawl goes from 2009 to 2016 with such words as “Thanksgiving,” “Return,” “Art Basel,” and “MoMA.” It quickly becomes clear that they are re-creating Marina Abramović’s durational performance The Artist Is Present, which debuted at the Museum of Modern Art in 2010 and was documented in a 2012 film.

I visited Abramović’s MoMA show, which re-created many of her most famous pieces along with various video projects, several times. I saw her unique theatrical production, The Life and Death of Marina Abramović, at Park Avenue Armory in 2013. I experienced her gallery show “Generator,” in which visitors had to put on blindfolds and noise-canceling headphones.

But my Abramović obsession pales in comparison to Miriam’s in The Seven Year Disappear.

Miriam (Cynthia Nixon) is a performance artist whose work exists in the shadow of Abramović’s worldwide popularity. It’s 2009, and she’s furious that her rival has just received a major commission from the Whitney. “She’s such a fucking hypocrite,” Miriam tells her twenty-three-year-old son, Naphtali (Taylor Trensch). “I love Marina, she’s a friend . . . But God, this makes me so fucking mad.”

She rails against Abramović’s 2005 presentation of “Seven Easy Pieces” at the Guggenheim, arguing, “Re-creating seven famous performance pieces over seven nights, seven hours each night — how original!” Naphtali says, “Well — two of them were her own,” to which Miriam replies, “And five of them were not. ‘Seven Easy Pieces’ . . . yeah, art is easy when you just copy it.”

When Naphtali tells his mother that MoMA is going to commission a new work from her, Miriam is overjoyed. “I never liked the Whitney anyway,” she says. “Let them have Marina.”

New Group world premiere is its own performance art piece (photo by Monique Carboni)

Abramović doesn’t have any children, so Miriam has incorporated Naphtali into much of her work, perhaps as a kind of dig. (An epigraph in the script quotes Abramović: “I had three abortions because I was certain that [having a child] would be a disaster for my work. One only has limited energy in the body, and I would have had to divide it.”) For the MoMA piece, Naphtali will again be part of it, whether he wants to or not; Miriam has decided to disappear for seven years and seven months, without telling a soul where she will be or what she’ll be doing. Attempting to top Abramović, in this case the artist will not be present.

For ninety-five minutes, the narrative goes back and forth between 2009 and 2016, as Naphtali, who is a gay addict, meets with seven characters, all played by Nixon in different accents (and/or adding a small prop like glasses), from Miriam’s agent, Wolfgang, and MoMA curator Brayden to teenage manicurist Kaitlyn, private detective Nicole, and Tomás, who works with Naphtali on Hillary Clinton’s 2016 presidential campaign. Claiming that Naphtali is obsessed with Clinton, Tomás warns him, “She’s not your mom, ya know.”

Performance art is, by its very nature, conceptual and nonnarrative; theater, even the most experimental type, requires some form of storytelling, no matter how abstract or opaque.

In The Seven Year Disappear, Seavey (Homos, or Everyone in America; The Funny Pain) and director Scott Elliott (The Seagull/Woodstock, NY; Mercury Fur) try to have it both ways, and it fails miserably.

I remember eagerly walking through “The Artist Is Present,” a well-curated, well-designed exhibit that provided viewers a chance to breathe while experiencing the numerous, often participatory works. The Seven Year Disappear is an overstuffed muddle, throwing everything it can at the audience, which often doesn’t know where to look as live projections fight for attention with the two actors, who seem trapped by Qween Jean’s costumes and who occasionally bring out microphones for mostly unknown reasons. The set is by the usually innovative Derek McLane, with lighting by Jeff Croiter, sound by Rob Milburn and Michael Bodeen, and projections by John Narun that contribute to the confusion.

Early on, Trensch (Camelot, Hello, Dolly!) and Nixon (Rabbit Hole, The Little Foxes) rest at the front of the stage, their legs dangling over the lip, intimately connecting with the audience. But it’s not long before it all turns icy as Naphtali grows cold and distant, overwhelmed by a barrage of Lifetime-esque personal problems, and Nixon gets lost in a flurry of annoying characters doing annoying things in a hard-to-follow back-and-forth timeline.

I never got the opportunity to sit and stare with Abramović at MoMA, but, while watching The Seven Year Disappear, all too often I found myself staring in disbelief at her fictional archrival, which is not at all the same thing.

[Mark Rifkin is a Brooklyn-born, Manhattan-based writer and editor; you can follow him on Substack here.]

I LOVE YOU SO MUCH I COULD DIE

Mona Pirnot sits with her back to the audience throughout I Love You So Much I Could Die (photo by Jenny Anderson)

I LOVE YOU SO MUCH I COULD DIE
New York Theatre Workshop
79 East Fourth St. between Second & Third Aves.
Monday – Saturday through March 9, $65-$75
www.nytw.org

Almost forty years ago, I composed a eulogy for my father’s funeral but was unable to read it because I was too distraught; instead, one of my best friends read it for me. So I understand why Mona Pirnot performs her solo show, I Love You So Much I Could Die, about a family tragedy with her back to the audience and has a Microsoft text-to-speech tool read her story, interspersed with five songs she sings with an acoustic guitar without turning around. However, I’m not convinced that it’s the best way to share this specific narrative, which doesn’t live up to the technical aspects of the production.

The play starts with Pirnot walking down one of the aisles and onto Mimi Lien’s spare set, where she takes a seat on a ladderback chair at a folding table with a laptop, a water bottle, a microphone, and a lamp; a floor speaker and monitor are nearby. She opens the computer and pushes the space bar; a disconcerting, disembodied male AI voice begins, “I’ve been trying out different support groups. It has not been going well. I can’t seem to find the right group for me. And everything is on zoom. Which makes everything sadder than it already was. And everything was already sad.” The voice adds a moment later, “[The leader] asked if I wanted to share first. I did not. But I said okay. I shared my story and when I was done, the guy was like, oh my god that’s awful. And I was like, yep. And he was like, oh my god. And I was like . . . yeah.”

As the voice recites the text, audience members with sharp eyesight can follow along as each word is highlighted on the screen as it’s spoken, reminiscent of karaoke, especially when the amateur warbler might be a bit tipsy and/or tone deaf. The delivery is bumpy, with unexpected pauses and mispronunciations, particularly involving the name Shia LaBeouf.

Pirnot, wearing a comfortable jumpsuit (the costume is by Enver Chakartash), stops the program five times to perform melancholic songs, including “happy birthday whatever who cares,” “good time girl,” and “Home to You.” The tunes are slow, mournful, and self-deprecating; she introduces “good time girl” by explaining it is much better with a hardcore electric guitar solo, which she instead will perform with her mouth, and proceeds to sing, “I fell back into that hole I forgot was there / My ride drove off and left me in the middle of nowhere / mmm I’m gone / Don’t even know where I went.”

The story also goes back ten years, when Pirnot first met a playwright who “would later become quite famous. As famous as a playwright can get ha ha if playwrights can ever really get famous.” Although she never mentions him by name, it is the man she would eventually marry, Lucas Hnath, who has written such plays as Red Speedo, The Christians, A Doll’s House Part 2, and The Thin Place. Hnath is the director of I Love You So Much I Could Die and has noted in interviews that one of the reasons he opted for Pirnot to sit with her back to the audience because that is how he saw her when she was writing the piece. For added intimacy, the lamp on the table is from their home.

I Love You So Much I Could Die is part of an unofficial trilogy (with maybe more to come?) in which Hnath explores unique methods to tell stories using old and new sound technology in one-person shows. In Dana H., Deirdre O’Connell won a Tony without speaking a word, instead lip-synching to an interview Hnath’s mother gave about her abduction by a member of the Aryan Brotherhood. In A Simulacram, actor, magician, and illusion designer Steve Cuiffo discusses his life and career by using an in-ear device to communicate live with a cassette recording of Hnath, re-creating exact conversations they had over the course of more than fifty hours of workshopping.

Dana H. and A Simulacram were both fascinating plays with compelling, entertaining stories to tell; unfortunately, I Love You So Much I Could Die falls short in that respect. Perhaps Hnath is too close to this one; the play might be a great way for Pirnot (Private, the world is full on) to deal with her personal situation, but it’s not an unusual one, even though she does not give specific details of what happened. In addition, the final section feels manipulative, tossed in to elicit a last surge of emotional melodrama.

While the AI’s voice is clear and crisp, it is often difficult to make out everything Pirnot is singing in her slow, eerily quiet tunes. (The sound design is by Mikhail Fiksel, with music direction by Will Butler.) Throughout the play’s sixty-five minutes, Oona Curley’s lighting dims nearly imperceptibly throughout the theater, ending in complete darkness.

I was hoping that at the conclusion, Pirnot would get off the chair and make her way to the door at the back left of the theater, never showing herself to the audience, but instead she turned around and smiled as she bowed. It’s not that didn’t deserve applause, but I thought it was a lost opportunity to add a special coda to this very private play.

[Mark Rifkin is a Brooklyn-born, Manhattan-based writer and editor; you can follow him on Substack here.]

PUBLIC OBSCENITIES

Jakeem Dante Powell (Raheem) and Abrar Haque (Choton) uncover a family secret in Shayok Misha Chowdhury’s Public Obscenities (photo by Hollis King)

PUBLIC OBSCENITIES
Theatre for a New Audience, Polonsky Shakespeare Center
262 Ashland Pl. between Lafayette Ave. & Fulton St.
Tuesday – Sunday through February 25, $97-$132
866-811-4111
www.tfana.org

Shayok Misha Chowdhury’s bilingual Public Obscenities is the surprise hit of the season. Following its sold-out run at Soho Rep, it moved to Theatre for a New Audience’s Polonsky Shakespeare Center, where it’s been extended through February 25.

Writer-director Chowdhury immerses the audience in Indian culture from the very beginning, as commercials for Indian products are projected onto a large screen like ads before a movie. Behind the screen is Peiyi Wong’s set, the interior of a house in South Kolkata with a mattress on the floor to the left, a refrigerator in the back, a table and chairs at the right, and a curtained-off kitchen (one character calls it “a mausoleum”); you can almost smell the Indian spices simmering throughout the family drama.

Choton (Abrar Haque), a Bengali American PhD student, has returned to South Kolkata with his boyfriend, Raheem (Jakeem Dante Powell), a Black cinematographer from America. They are staying with Choton’s aunt Pishimoni (Gargi Muhkerjee) and uncle Pishe (Debashis Roy Chowdhury), who are caring for Choton’s ailing, bedridden paternal grandmother, Thammi; Jitesh (Golam Sarwar Harun) runs the household and cares for Thammi. Looming over everything is a stern-looking portrait of Choton’s late grandfather, Dadu.

Choton is in Kolkata because he is applying for a dissertation fellowship at the University of Chicago. He’s working on a queer archiving project, planning to interview people he finds over Grindr, eventually meeting with Tashnuva Anan (Shou), who is kothi, and Sebanti (NaFis), who is hijra, two types of nonbinary and/or transgender identities in India. Meanwhile, Pishe is secretly chatting with a much younger single mother who lives in Minnesota.

Acknowledging Raheem’s interest in photography, Pishimoni asks Jitesh to show Raheem an old Rolleicord camera owned by Dadu. Raheem notices that there is still film in the camera, and when they examine it, they make a shocking discovery.

Pishimoni (Gargi Muhkerjee) makes a point to Raheem (Jakeem Dante Powell) in Public Obscenities (photo by Hollis King)

The Soho Rep and NAATCO National Partnership Project’s production of Public Obscenities, copresented by TFANA and Woolly Mammoth, might be three hours long (including intermission), but it flies by; Chowdhury makes the audience feel like it’s part of the family, even when the Hindi is not translated into English.

The intergenerational drama not only smartly explores gender identity and sexual orientation but uses technology to advance the plot and define the characters. Choton has trouble operating Raheem’s camera on his own. Raheem uses the sixty-year-old Rolleicord to show us Thammi, while we see Choton’s father only over FaceTime. Old printed-out photos reveal another side of Dadu. Meanwhile, Johnny Moreno’s cinematic projections move the action from the house to a riverbank, and one scene plays out as a prerecorded film.

The ensemble is terrific, led by Haque in his impressive New York City debut, Muhkerjee (Women on Fire: Stories from the Frontlines, The Namesake) as the inquisitive Pishimoni, Harun (Marat-Sade, Mrichchakatikam) providing occasional comedy as Jitesh, and Anan, who is a revelation as Shou. Enver Chakartash’s costumes, Barbara Samuels’s lighting, and Tei Blow’s sound, which includes outdoor nature tones echoing through the theater, further immerses the audience into Indian culture.

Public Obscenities moved from Soho Rep to TFANA as part of the Under the Radar festival, but the secret is out; the show is no longer flying under the radar.

[Mark Rifkin is a Brooklyn-born, Manhattan-based writer and editor; you can follow him on Substack here.]